Bass Pro Shops Ratings and Reviews
Shop Now At Bass Pro Shops
Shop Shooting Accessories or
Choose a Category

Customer Reviews for Butler Creek Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines

Butler Creek Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines

25-round magazine Superior, no jam feed lip design Self-lubricating polymer feed lip in Hot Lips models or stainless steel feed lip in Steel Lips models Magazines design allows for magazines to be hooked together for multi-feeding mags Works with Hot Lips speed loader (sold separately) Eliminate jammed feeds frequent reloading in your Ruger 10/22 with this 25-round magazine. 25-round magazine is capable of feeding all types of 22LR ammo. Separately molded flat feeder lip made of an extremely tough self-lubricating polymer (Hot Lips) or stainless steel (Steel Lips) ensures consistent, reliable feeding. Constant-force spring allows uniform, easy loading. This clip will provide you with thousands of hours of shooting pleasure. Magazine's design allows for mags to be hooked together to make multi-feeding mags. Can be loaded in seconds with the 50-round Hot Lips loader (sold separately). Fits Ruger 10/22, Ruger 77/22, and AMT Lightning.Made in USA. Butler Creek® Hot Lips® Loader page
Average Customer Rating:
3.3 out of 5
3.3
 out of 
5
(20 Reviews) 20
Rating Snapshot
Open Ratings Snapshot
Rating Snapshot (20 reviews)
5 stars
8
4 stars
2
3 stars
3
2 stars
2
1 star
5
11 of 20(55%)customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Questions & Answers:
5 Questions | 6 Answers
Terms of Use
Customer Reviews for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Review 1 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
1 out of 5
1 out of 5

Waste of money

,
May 13, 2012
By Anonymous
Disadvantages: Performance, Quality, Durability, multiple jams, wont cycle when fully loaded
"I bought 2 of these mags and they are absolutely worthless. They claim to hold 25 rounds but if you load more than 10 rounds the spring is stretched to far and they will not raise the round enough to load.They also fit very loose into the gun so even with 10 rounds you still get multiple jams. Save your money and get the actual ruger mags which are a lot better."
Would you recommend this product as a gift? No
Review 2 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
4 out of 5
4 out of 5

Butler Creek 25 round magazine

,
May 7, 2012
By jjeveryday
Advantages: Ease of use, Performs well
Disadvantages: doesnt fit tightly
"Butler Creek Steel Lips Banana Magazines 25 round magazine is very good 25 round clip, its steel lips and feed seem pretty decent, i had a few jams after 200 rounds. I think its cause of the model, its seems to be loose when inside the rifle, could improve on it by making it tighter and stay in place. main reason for jamming is probably the lose magazine."
Review 3 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
1 out of 5
1 out of 5

STEEL LIPS = YES, HOT LIPS = NO

,
January 24, 2012
By Stripermaniac
from Kittery, Maine
"Butler creek has a decent history with the Ruger 10/22 following but if you are going to purchase a high capacity mag from them do yourself a favor and GET THE STEEL LIPS, NOT THE HOT LIPS.
The Hot Lips are an all plastic and polymer design and are junk for lack of a better term.
The Steel Lips are GREAT. I love mine. I wish you could disassemble this mag like Ruger's high-capacity mag or the steel lipped versions made by Tactical Innovations.
The steel lips mag does require some cleaning to ensure smooth ammo feeding but mine has been very dependable. Although it cannot be disassembled for cleaning there is a small hole at the bottom of the mag that allows for residue to pass through when soaked with Rem Oil of other gun oils.
I have cycled full 25 round mags with the Steel Lips in rapid succession and had no issues, but I have also watched Hot Lips fail and break under normal usage."
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Review 4 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

Awesome Product

,
January 19, 2012
By Kais
Advantages: Ease of use, Durability, Performs well, Value for money, Quality
"This product works great. I recently bought a ruger 10/22 and thought the stock mag ran out of ammo way to quickly and decided to try this. It is a great replacement for just a few more dollars than the stock mag."
What do you usually hunt? Other
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 5 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
2 out of 5
2 out of 5

More Like 15-round

,
October 27, 2011
By Glenith
Disadvantages: Performance, Quality
"It may look cool, but the spring inside was way too strong. We had to replace the spring because my 10/22 was jamming. It was frustrating and i would not recommend it. It worked well if you only put 15 in, but there was no way that 25 would fit. I would recommend the 10-round magazines because they are just much more reliable."
Review 6 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
2 out of 5
2 out of 5

Too quick to action

,
August 15, 2011
By Demand
from Warner Robins, GA
Advantages: Ease of use, Performs well
Disadvantages: same product available at half price
"Had one shooting experience with some friends and everything performed perfectly. I was surprised to learn that the product cost was twice that of all my friends. Next time I won't move so quickly."
What do you usually hunt? Deer
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 7 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

Lots of fun

,
June 15, 2011
By DGB4
from Utah
Advantages: Ease of use, Performs well, Quality
Disadvantages: go through a lot of ammo
"I have several other banana clips and they are a lot of fun to shoot. The steel lips seem to fit easier into my 10/22. I liked them enough that I now have five of them."
What do you usually hunt? Other
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 8 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
4 out of 5
4 out of 5

Not for high velocity HP

,
April 24, 2011
By Westendguy
Advantages: Ease of use, Durability, Performs well
"Works great with solid point regular velocity or Federal high velocity hollow point. Tends to jam with CCI high velocity HP. My son has 6 clips - 2 taped together at a time. Need to tape them as they tend to come apart. He's put through over a 1,000 rounds of the solid point with very few jams. CCI jams regularly. Overall, pretty cool setup with his Ruger SR22."
Review 9 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

love it

,
April 16, 2011
By duke7
Advantages: Durability, Performs well, Value for money, Quality
"this is an aosum clip. i already have one for my 22LR and im wantin another"
What do you usually hunt? Deer
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 10 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
3 out of 5
3 out of 5

Seen Better

,
February 28, 2011
By MountianManHuntingEq
from Mercersburg PA
Advantages: Ease of use
Disadvantages: Performance, poor spring tention
"Thought I would do myself a favor and elude the jamming problem found in plastic loading surface clips, NOT!!!!! Steel Top clips jam just as much, single shot till I have only 18 rounds left. Sure not worth the extra money. Ruger Certified clips are all I'll buy or sell now, too many complaints."
What do you usually hunt? Other
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? No
Review 11 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

Butler Creek 10/22 25rd mag

,
January 28, 2011
By Nyrad
Advantages: Performs well
"Have shot a couple hundred rounds with this mag with no problems. Plan to purchase a couple more of these mags."
Review 12 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

ruger 22LR magazine

,
May 24, 2010
By kpstews
from connecticut
Advantages: Ease of use, Durability, Performs well, Value for money
"These magazines are one of the few that don't jam at all. The single stack design, instead of the staggered stack clips, work flawlessly. Have gone thru 300 rounds without one jam or stovepipe.
Great mag for the price!!
"
What do you usually hunt? Deer
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 13 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
3 out of 5
3 out of 5

You can't win them all

,
November 26, 2008
By FriscoKid
from Frisco, TX
"I have two of these mags, and I rarely have a jam, but they do happen from time to time with mine. Some people have had terrible luck with these and some others have never had a jam. I guess it's just a roll of the dice. I wouldn't recommend anything but the factory mags if jamming really lights your fuse."
What do you usually hunt? Deer
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 14 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
1 out of 5
1 out of 5

peice of junk

,
September 18, 2008
By madashell
from Ohio
"I would of give this product a zero but one is as low as it would go. It jams every shot, it wont throw the shell into the chamber. You can only load ten shots for it to work right, sometimes the spring won't come up at all. It don't fit in the gun right."
What do you usually hunt? Other
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? No
Review 15 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
1 out of 5
1 out of 5

not worth buying

,
March 2, 2008
By familyguy223
"i bought two of these because i go through the 10 round mags in a flash, but both 25 round mags jam after every shot. they fit loosely into the gun, and you can jiggle it back and forth and up and down. i would suggest that you save your 20 dollars and buy the butler creek ammo feeder, and a few more 10 round rotary clips, the feeder really cuts back on time wasted trying to manually load your magazines."
What do you usually hunt? Other
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? No
Review 16 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
3 out of 5
3 out of 5

You get what you pay for

,
February 27, 2008
By gzar
from Mississippi
"At $20 these clips are worth buying - but don't expect them to be problem free. The Hot Lips reloader works great on these - no loading problems at all.
I purchased 2 of these & both have issues:
1) The magazine sticks too far into the receiver so the red block actually can jam the 10/22 gun action. After inserting, pull back down a tad and it's not too bad.
2) The clips do not fight tightly once inserted - they stick down quite a ways (as expected) but can be easily bumped/jarred about a half-inch forward/backwards to cause alignment issues with the gun slide.
3) Because of issue 2 - they jam an awful lot. I've put just under 2 bricks (1000ish) rounds through these and have yet to get a single 25-round clip to function for 25 shots without a jam.
Still - at $20 they are worth having compared to hand-loading the 10-rnd ruger clips all the time. Jams & all, combined with the speedloader I spend more time shooting & less time reloading than I did with factory ruger clips.
"
What do you usually hunt? Other
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 17 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

either good or bad

,
December 11, 2007
By Sirs
from NC
"if you read ruger's site they will tell you these are just as good as their own magazines but there is quality control problem so if you get one bad normally whole batch is bad if it's good whole batch is good."
What do you usually hunt? Deer
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 11+
Would you recommend this product as a gift? Yes
Review 18 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

best thing since the wheel

,
July 8, 2007
By BUDMAN
"I have 2 Ruger 10/22 rifles and was tired of reloading the 10 round mags. I now own 9 of these hit lips mags. Now it's fun shooting with the kids. (Need to use the quik reloader)"
Review 19 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
1 out of 5
1 out of 5

NOT HAPPY

,
December 31, 2006
By SCHNEIDER
from WHEELING IL
"WITH MY NEW 10/22 I PICKED UP 4 OF THE HOT LIPS MAGS NOT ONE OF THE MAGS WORKED WILL, DOUBLE FEEDS AND JAMS ALL DAY LONG. SWITCHED TO 10 ROUND EAGLE MAGS AND PUT 200 ROUNDS WITH NOT ONE JAM."
What do you usually hunt? Other
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 1-2
1 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Review 20 for Butler Creek® Hot Lips® or Steel Lips Banana Magazines
Overall Rating:
5 out of 5
5 out of 5

Great Product

,
October 28, 2006
By hansen93
from Windsor, CO
"Fits and funtions perfectly in my ruger 10/22. I have not had a jam using this product."
What do you usually hunt? Other
How many times a year do you hunt on average? 1-2
Terms of Use